A disappointment. Robert Parker wrote this up in Decemeber '04 and gave it a great review, saying that it had managed to avoid the harsh tannin and astringency that has plagued many wines from the south of France (and Spain) in this vintage of unprecedented heat. On the strength of that review, I snagged a couple of bottles at Cost Plus several months ago at $23.99 (a great price for a good Chateauneuf!). Stashed 'em in the closet. In the most recent Wine Advocate, however, he re-reviewed it and apparently changed his mind: says it's astringent and tannic.
So I opened a bottle to see what was up. Crap. It was indeed astringent and harsh.
Deep, yet dullish black ruby color (I've noticed that many 2003s from the Southern Rhone, Provence, and the Languedoc have dull color). Nose of scorched earth and graphite, with some simple blackberry fruit in the background. Fairly full-bodied, with straightforward black fruit and peppery charcoal flavors. Rough tannin and astringency are the main components of the finish. Rustic and simple, this wine is not in any way identifiable as a Chateauneuf -- tastes like a generic and pedestrian Cotes du Rhone instead. 79.
I'm going to let the second bottle sit for a year or so and see if anything changes for the better, but I doubt it will.
2003 Perrin Chateauneuf du Pape "Les Sinards" (Rhone, France)
Labels:
Grenache,
Rhône (and Provence)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(465)
-
▼
March
(35)
- 2003 Patient Cottat Sancerre "Vieilles Vignes"
- 2004 Coron Pere & Fils St. Veran "Domaine de Monta...
- And Then You Have...
- The Unhinged Values Voters Conference
- Texas Alcohol Beverage Commission Engaging in Pett...
- TV is NOT Liberal
- Red State Update 20: March of the Mexicans
- 2002 Yalumba "Bush Vines" Grenache (Barossa Valley...
- This is Family Values???
- Anti-Gay Marriage Amendments a Problem for Straights
- 2003 Mas Carlot Costieres de Nimes "Les Enfants Te...
- 2004 Bonny Doon "Vin Gris de Cigare" Rosé
- Dems Feeling the Heat
- Reprehensible Attitude
- Bush Admin. Funneling Millions to Faith-Based Prog...
- A Nutcase Site-Must Read
- And WHO is a Threat to Society?
- 2003 Domaine Paul Blanck Alsace Riesling (France)
- 2003 Cline "Ancient Vines" Zinfandel (California)
- I Hate Updating!
- 2002 Hill of Content Grenache/Shiraz (South Austra...
- 2003 Finca Luzon Jumilla (Spain)
- Red State Update 19: Moussaoui Trial
- 2004 Viña Antigua Sangiovese/Bonarda (Maipu, Argen...
- 2003 Perrin Chateauneuf du Pape "Les Sinards" (Rho...
- A Little Message for Republicans
- Report: Gay Prevention Programs Harm Teens
- More Reaming of Hillary
- The Danger of Dildos
- U.S. Women Forced to Give Birth in Shackles
- Film Won't Fix Society
- Christian TV empire savors a tax blessing
- 2004 Woop Woop Shiraz (Southeast Australia)
- One Time Too Many
- Wednesday Laughs
-
▼
March
(35)